What is it like to write during what could be the last decades of human civilization?
In this week’s episode, Dr. Ed Simon talks about his latest book Writing During the Apocalypse Reflections on the Great Unraveling (Bloomsbury).
Rising authoritarianism. Covid. Inflation. Wealth disparity. War. Climate change. While every time period is marked by apocalyptic fears, it certainly seems like our current anxieties aren't ill placed. And yet, art and literature persist. In his new book, Ed grapples with the notion that writers and their work ought to distract readers from our currently dire situation.
Examining creativity as it has manifested in similarly dire circumstances in human history – in a broad range of authors and texts, such as the Bible, Boccaccio's Decameron, Voltaire, Octavia Butler's Parable of the Sower, and Stephen King's The Stand – Writing During the Apocalypse eschews the easy defeatism of nihilism. Instead, it offers a hopeful perspective on the various ways that literary expression can endow a meaningless world with meaning and generate a spark in the darkness.
With the infamous four horsemen as its guide, Writing During the Apocalypse honors the literary life even during the end of the world.
Ed argues that to craft imaginative spaces through the magic of words isn't superfluous. Instead it exists at the core of human experience – as it always has and always will.
-
Alison Stratten (00:00)
Today on Academic Book Club, it is my pleasure to welcome the author of Writing During the Apocalypse: Reflections on the Great Unraveling, Ed Simon, a public humanities lecturer in the English department at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, and the founding editor of Pittsburgh Review of Books.
authoritarianism, COVID, inflation, wealth disparity, war, climate change. While every time period is marked by apocalyptic fears, it certainly seems like our current anxieties aren't ill-placed. And yet, art and literature persist. In his new book, published by Bloomsbury, Ed grapples with the notion that writers and their work ought to distract readers from the currently dire situation.
Ed argues that to craft imaginative spaces through the magic of words isn't superfluous. Instead, it exists as the core of human experience, as it always has and as it always will.
Alison Stratten (00:56)
Thank you so much for taking the time to be here with me today. If you would like
Ed S. (01:02)
Thank you.
Alison Stratten (01:02)
yeah, if you'd begin by telling me a little bit about yourself and how you came to write your new book.
Ed S. (01:08)
Sure. Uh so my name's Ed Simon, and I'm a public humanities lecturer at the English department at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh. Um, and I'm also the founding editor of the Pittsburgh Review of Books there. Uh and I've I've write publicly for a lot of different sorts of venues and have a couple different trade books I I've done. Um Writing During the Apocalypse is a book that came out last November, I think, of last year. Uh and it is for the most part a compilation of
previously written works that kind of engage with the question of what does it mean to be alive at this particular point in time when it seems like everything is uh is going off the rails. So the book itself wasn't I mean some books you write where you have in mind like this is the thing I want to do and you begin, you know, from start to finish and everything is cohesive in that way. And this was more kind of an acknowledgement of something I'd been writing about in a kind of an unorganized way already.
And kind of bringing some form and structure to some of those thoughts.
Alison Stratten (02:10)
Yeah, can you tell me maybe a little bit about some of the authors or other books that sort of informed you when you were doing the writing?
Ed S. (02:18)
Yeah, so I think um, you know, the the book was published by Bloomsbury Academic. So it is uh an academic book, but it's marketed kind of as like trade adjacent in some ways. Uh and uh part of that the academic framing was thinking of it as auto theory, which like in creative nonfiction you just call that memoir for the most part,
Alison Stratten (02:38)
Yeah.
Ed S. (02:38)
right? But basically like theoretically informed, strong first person narrative writing, right? That's autobiographical in some way.
I think I was really interested very much influenced by someone like uh Amative Ghosh and his writing on like the the Anthropocene. I think uh Roy William uh Scruton has been a huge, huge influence on me. He's a tremendous writer, I believe at Notre Dame right now. Um, but he writes a lot about this idea of the Anthropocene. Uh and a lot of his writing is very much personally inflected in that way. Um so thinking about when you're writing about you know the
kind of poly crisis that we face right now. Uh, how it is um a phenomenon that is so huge, right? Because you're talking about climate change and economic concerns and wealth stratification and militarism and nationalism, that it's hard to kind of get like a a bead on that because it's so many different things at once. But then of course we're all in it and we're all part of it as well. So by necessity, I think the stories can be very personal.
but
they're they're kind of like a limited part of it in some way, right? By kind of, you know, for good and for bad. And I think uh Scruton has really given me, Scranton, I'm sorry, has given me like really a sense of how one can kind of tell their own story um through this kind of broader collection of things that are happening.
Alison Stratten (04:06)
Like bridging them together, kind of.
Ed S. (04:08)
Yeah,
exactly. And in and part of this book that I've written, um, you know, some sections are much more historically informed or kind of traditionally analytical. Uh, and then there are these kind of letters that are dispersed throughout, which are my own kind of personal reactions to th things that you know I'm witnessing or that I'm somewhat adjacent to, but not in any kind of historical way. I'm not like a a prime mover for any of these things.
And like everyone else, I'm just kind of you know, on on the in the audience for it. Um, but some of it is about how does one personally grapple with these sorts of things.
Alison Stratten (04:47)
Can you can you speak
a little? You mentioned that it was writing that you done previously. Can you just speak a little bit about that in terms of
Ed S. (04:54)
Yeah.
Alison Stratten (04:54)
putting the book together and really the nuts and bolts of sort of the process of that? I mean, you have a busy schedule as you mentioned, you're doing all kinds of things. Can you speak a little bit about that about putting the book together?
Ed S. (05:06)
Yeah, so a lot of these there was a a series of essays that I wrote back when I was a staff writer for the millions, and the millions was um it still exists, but it was kind of a book blog website that had been founded a little bit more than 20 years ago now. Uh and I had a monthly column there, and I began to do this kind of unconsciously do this series where it would be like letters from the whatever, right? So I have something about COVID, and it'll be like letters from the pandemic.
Um, or something about uh the January 6th insurrection. And it's like letters from the insurrection. And so I kind of developed this rhetorical tick of phrasing these things as letters from. And it was a little bit of a different idiom from most of the work that I wrote for them, where I was not necessarily particularly present as a character. Uh, and I was much more so in these particular pieces. And so when I began um thinking about
Making a book in which these would be included along with like newer material. This is about 2023, I think, when I began to think about that.
Alison Stratten (06:10)
Yeah.
Ed S. (06:11)
I had by that point a collection of these sorts of like letters. and I thought that there was something interesting about them as kind of like a first draft of scholarship that is like apt to get things wrong or to be kind of written in the f the fog of current events.
But that I thought would be interesting to have them placed alongside things that are a little bit more traditionally, in some ways, um scholarship, right? In some kind, in some kind of way. So the letters themselves, I think the earliest one in there is like 2016. Uh, and that's Letter from the Singularity. It's the one about technocracy and technology. Uh, and that was originally written for um something called the marginalia review of books. And then I think every other letter, maybe except for one, had been written from the millions.
Um,
but they basically stretch up to about 2021. I don't think there's anything that's after 21. And then the book comes out in 25, 26, obviously. So one of the interesting things is, you know, when I've been at book events and I've read some of these letters, there are things that not that I disagree with what my reaction to things was at the time, but like the information's incomplete, obviously. Uh, and
Alison Stratten (07:20)
Yeah.
Ed S. (07:20)
some of the stuff that I'm um normally some of the stuff that I was optimistic about didn't bear fruit, honestly.
but uh I I think that that's part of the intentionality behind the book as well, right? Is because um when you have uh me at this point writing about my reactions to something in 2020, that's my reaction from 2020, right? And that's I think part of the point of those letters is it it brings you back to those kinds of historical junctures.
Alison Stratten (07:50)
It's very powerful
too, I think, as a reader, because we all experience these things as
Ed S. (07:55)
Thank you.
Alison Stratten (07:55)
one person. And so you read it and we all have those experiences of of not whatever we saw at the time not ending up being what actually came to place. And so I
Ed S. (08:05)
Yeah.
Alison Stratten (08:06)
I think that's very powerful as a reader as well.
Ed S. (08:09)
And some of it was, you know, I lived a very uh parapetic, I can never pronounce it, uh, existence for a long time. Um, so these pieces are written in certain locales. like the Letter from the Singularity was living in New York at the time. Um, the pandemic letters, the insurrection letters are mostly from Washington, DC, uh, or from like within the Beltway in Virginia. And so I had you know, kind of Zelig like, I guess, I found myself in these certain circumstances where
history is sort happening around me in some ways. So, you know, DC uh got hit pretty badly by the pandemic and my wife is a ER physician, so she, you know, was witness to a lot of that sort of stuff. Or we were you know, we were living in Capitol Hill, literally six blocks from the Capitol building in the lead up to the insurrection. Uh so there's this kind of you know, some of it's seeing things through a television screen and s or a phone and some of it's kind of
Just being present in certain circumstances, you know. And I think one of the things that's interesting to me, like with the the COVID chapters in DC, uh, is um, you know, DC was never as bad as New York, for example, for the sheer number of fatalities, but it was worse than a lot of places. Uh, and uh there was just this kind of continual wail of ambulances that you would hear as people were being taken off to the ER. Uh, and this was at the same time that you had um
the Black Lives Matter protests were gaining steam. Um, and Trump at the time uh, you know, brought the National Guard from several like red states into the city. So the city was kind of occupied, and there was a very strictly maintained curfew that was going on. Uh and s some of my friends that lived in places that did not have that same sort of experience, like don't remember that sort of stuff. You know, like
when I say,
Alison Stratten (10:00)
Yeah.
Ed S. (10:01)
well, you know, DC was like occupied at the time.
And they're like, yeah, I guess I remember that, right? So there's a certain amount of um the way in which geography gives one a different sense of what's happening.
Alison Stratten (10:13)
Yeah, so you've you've spoken about this a little bit already, but I'm hoping you'll touch on a few different points. W now that the book is out, when you look back upon it, what is some of them you've mentioned, but what other things sort of stand out for someone who might want to pick up the book, or there any sort of in a reflective sort of look at it that really stand out for you or that you feel are really applicable? I think most of it is, but especially applicable right now.
Ed S. (10:39)
I think one the things that's interesting with the book ah is you know, I never I sometimes I feel like I'm being a uh a jerk when I'm like, I was really prescient on certain things, right? Or or whatever. And I don't think that I am. I think lots of people see the writing on the wall in all kinds of different ways. And it's just sort of a an issue of awareness and and connecting the dots. And there's a there's a reason why all of the mechanisms of
media and business and government serve to kind of um anesthesize people from um an awareness of what we can see with our own eyes, right? And you
Alison Stratten (11:17)
Yeah.
Ed S. (11:18)
know, it's uh we had you know, I live in Pittsburgh right now, my hometown of Pittsburgh. it's what September 10th. And a couple days ago it was like 95 degrees, right? Uh and like this is um I'm in my 40s. I uh when I was a kid in Pittsburgh, it was
yellow and brown and orange leaves right now that were falling. There was like a slight crisp in the air. Uh and I think any anyone of a certain age knows that this is not normal, right? Uh and yet
Alison Stratten (11:49)
Yes. m
Ed S. (11:50)
we kind of function in this the term is hyper normalization that I that I borrow that I use in the book. There's a way in which like it doesn't really serve everything to keep working the way that those in power want things to work for us to be like
Wait, my god, why is it 95 in September? And so we kind of like plod along with it. And I think that, you know, one of the things when I go back and I look at the older essays, um, is this or that detail are definitely wrong. But I think the broad trends are strike me by how correct they can be. And I attribute no special clairvoyance to myself for that. I think that like anyone paying attention.
can sort of see those things. I mean one of the one of the most interesting essays there for me is the the technology one because that's 10 years old now. and you know this is five, six years, seven years, whenever ChatGPT 3 was released. I mean, there's no discussion of the things that we now know what this stuff is called when it was written, because it didn't exist yet. But this kind of worry about artificial intelligence and generative intelligence, but then even more so a worry about the ideologies
that
kind of foist those uh upon the public, more so than the technology itself even. Um
Alison Stratten (13:08)
Yeah.
Ed S. (13:09)
but then it's interesting, you know, it it it kind of has that feeling of you're reading like a a science fiction novel that like, you know, it gets it gets the names of things wrong, but the the trends kind of follow.
Alison Stratten (13:21)
Yeah, did anything really surprise you? Like being in the the area and writing about these for so long when you actually put everything together, was there anything where you were like, I didn't like see that trend in my even in my own work, or I didn't notice that I had kind of like been moving in that direction. Did anything surprise you putting it together?
Ed S. (13:45)
think with the political chapter, um, you know, this this book was basically finished before Trump was uh elected a second time. Um
Alison Stratten (13:55)
Yeah.
Ed S. (13:56)
I think that like I was looking at galleys at that point. Uh and so we had to go back in, and in like uh the introduction, I think like one or two lines had to be changed to reflect the the new reality of things.
Alison Stratten (14:07)
Yeah.
Ed S. (14:09)
I I used to have, because I, you know, sometimes a joke, I was like, I don't want to be on my deathbed. I'm not gonna be in my deathbed like I wish I'd written more.
Donald Trump, right? Because I have found that I've written quite a bit uh about him. And it's hard not to because he's the dominant political figure of the past decade, you know, in the United States, certainly, if not, if not the world. But I used to have this kind of idea that, you know, after he lost in uh in 20, that I would like gather all of the things I'd written over the previous four years, and you'd have kind of this omnibus that could be like a historical curio. and
Alison Stratten (14:41)
Yeah.
Ed S. (14:42)
I at a certain point.
I think I knew he was probably gonna win reelection that summer as I was working on things. I had that kind of um that sinking sense of that.
Alison Stratten (14:51)
Yeah.
Ed S. (14:51)
Uh but I think there is a bit of a whiplash with the kind of like, well we dodged this one bullet, fully understanding that he is like a a symptom of of the disease and not the disease itself. but the kind of rapid whiplash, I think, has has been surprising.
The other thing that I'll say that I I don't mention in the technology chapter, I mean the portions that were written uh more recently, obviously, where I I'm privy to that, but the one from 10 years ago is I didn't have a sense of how much artificial intelligence could lead to a kind of epistemic collapse. And so the kind of way in which we're like inundated with um AI slop that is like obviously fake.
and how convincing that is to people or how the algorithm kind of collectively rewrites people's way of approaching the world, whether you want it to or not, to an extent. Um so when I'm, you know, I'll be like faculty meetings or whatever, and we talk about what our policies should be in terms of AI writing, and I'll pause and it feels uncanny. It feels like you're in a science fiction novel where all of a sudden we're like, well, what do we do if robots write, you know, work for our students or whatever. Uh and there's a surrealism to that.
And
I I don't think that particular detail was something I anticipated.
Alison Stratten (16:13)
Yeah. It's hard to even imagine that. So it's hard to perceive that, I think. So
Ed S. (16:17)
Sure.
Alison Stratten (16:18)
yeah. You asked sort of a big question in the book about the role of sort of writers and you know, I don't want to say culture, but cultural creators, but
Ed S. (16:29)
Yeah.
Alison Stratten (16:29)
the the role of sort of is it the role of an of an author to distract? Is it is it the role of art stud can you speak a little bit about that and whether you sort of found any answers to that i it through putting the book together?
Ed S. (16:44)
I think for like a long time I had been thinking, you know, because climate change is one of these like ID fixes of mine that I keep coming back to time and time again. Uh and that goes back for like decades. And one of the things I think about is you know, we have this idea that one writes to posterity, which I suppose I mean, it's a very optimistic, personally optimistic view. If you're like, I'm writing forever and like, you know, most of us write for like a day if we're lucky. Uh
Alison Stratten (17:10)
For lucky.
Ed S. (17:11)
and so there's a certain amount of like
you know what I guess what's the point is kind of the one of the things, right? And I was just interested in that question of what the the point was. Uh and then this a lot of this book um is really stuck in like the summer of 21 for me. Uh
Alison Stratten (17:28)
Yeah.
Ed S. (17:29)
and that's the sort of thing, you know, it's a time period we were living um in McLean, Virginia, which is kind of like a dystopian place. Uh and uh you know my wife was still working in the ER. I was taking care of our our newborn son.
you couldn't go anywhere yet, everything was still on lockdown, the political situation was not good. and uh it was just in a a really depressive kind of state because of that. And so a lot of it was thinking through if we are facing some kind of collapse, and at times I think it definitely seems that way, why bother? Right. And one of the things that I found, and there's a couple different answers I give.
To this throughout the book. And I don't know if any of them are definitive so much as me just kind of spitballing. But for me,
Alison Stratten (18:12)
Yeah.
Ed S. (18:13)
because I am a person who like um my identity as a writer is really intrinsic to myself in terms of how I view and understand the world. Uh
Alison Stratten (18:22)
Yeah.
Ed S. (18:22)
and the fact that some of that writing is published is like a wonderful bonus to me. Like I love having readers and like getting an occasional paycheck is great and and whatever else. Uh but really I I write to understand what I think about things.
And so the writing, the process of writing is as important as the product. And so many of these letters came out of uh okay, well, I just saw a bunch of horrible stuff. Uh what do I what do I think about that? How do I place that in context? It's a it's a type of thinking uh as much as it is any anything else. And so that's one of the justifications I give. And then there's others where you know people writing as a means of resistance, people writing as a means of um witness, uh, people writing as a means of um
recording or people writing as a a means of meaning making. So I think there's all kinds of and they're not mutually exclusive, but I there's all kinds of ways in which people write in the face of um tragedy or in the face of upcoming calamity, I guess.
Alison Stratten (19:21)
Yeah. I I think um I think it really speaks to that. I think it's like a communication mode also. Some people
Ed S. (19:27)
Yeah.
Alison Stratten (19:28)
communicate that way. They write novels to share how they feel. They make movies to share. So
Ed S. (19:33)
Yes.
Alison Stratten (19:33)
I think it can give you these beautiful nuances as well. Yeah.
Ed S. (19:36)
For sure, for sure.
Alison Stratten (19:38)
I um I'm wondering if you have, when you were writing or putting it together or now, do you have sort of spheres and spaces or readers, places that you hope
the book will travel or that you particularly had in mind when you were putting it together.
Ed S. (19:54)
It's interesting. I I would like younger readers for this because I, you know, I've taught for almost 20 years, uh, and I've found that as I get older, my students uh I feel like have more of a consciousness or awareness of things because it obviously affects them in a very direct kind of way, right? So they're kind of
much more radical now than they were in the past, in a way that I think is in encouraging in lots of ways. They also, I think, are um very depressed. They're pessimistic. They're not cynical, but they're pessimistic, I think. And so I appreciate not that I want to just like preach to the choir, uh, but one of the things I talk about with writing is at least like a sense of being like seen with things. And what I found with like events that we've had on on this
is that when people talk about all of the stuff that they notice, like, hey, have you noticed there aren't any bugs anymore, right? Hey, have you noticed that like Canada's on fire and I can't breathe when I go outside anymore? Right. Um, this stuff that like we're kind of acculturated not to notice, but that we do, there's a certain amount of like, I'm not, I'm not crazy, right? Uh not that I want to speak of this in purely therapeutic terms or something.
But I also don't think there's anything necessarily wrong with that in some ways. Uh and I found it's really funny, some of the some of the harshest criticism I feel like I've received from it is people might say, like, well, you know, I I don't think things are going great, but they're not as bad as this guy says, right? And I'm like, you know, not I'm not a climatologist, I'm not a computer scientist, I'm not a an international affairs policy expert or whatever. You know, but like.
You you go through the UN climate report and you read it and it's cited and it's quoted in there. Like, no, it very much is as bad as as as I think I I say here. Uh and so there's um I mean, sometimes I want those readers too. Uh, just because I think it's important, you know, I don't know what I don't think it's our responsibility per se, at least certainly not individually, to stop these things, but I do think we have to be cognizant of them.
uh and and plan accordingly, I guess.
Alison Stratten (22:11)
Yeah, I understand that. I think it's that first step of sharing those experiences that allows us to connect together and be able to do anything about them at all. So it's really powerful to give it into students' hands as well.
Ed S. (22:24)
For sure.
Alison Stratten (22:25)
I um I have one more question. I ask all authors this. I know it's a big cr
Ed S. (22:28)
Sure. okay.
Alison Stratten (22:30)
I know it's a big question. So authors often will write the books they wish they could read, like that you wish you could turn around and pull off your show.
Ed S. (22:38)
Yeah.
Alison Stratten (22:39)
Do you have any
sort of like books that you wish you were reading now or or that you wish you could turn around and be like this one,
Ed S. (22:46)
Yeah, yeah.
Alison Stratten (22:47)
this one right here.
Ed S. (22:48)
So I um I think that definitely motivates a lot of my um philosophy of what projects I like to work on. Um, so currently I'm I'm beginning a book uh that is a cultural history of the idea that everything is a simulation, that everything's an illusion, which is like
Alison Stratten (23:05)
Cool.
Ed S. (23:05)
I should emphasize, like I don't believe that. Like I don't think we're in a computer program, right? Um
But I'm interested in what an enduring idea that is from like Plato's Cave all the way up to like contemporary Silicon Valley people uh who believe that. And I think it tells us something very deep about how we understand human existence and knowledge and like what we know and what we can't know and all of these things. Uh and it's you know, I wrote a book that was a history of the Faust myth, and that was a very similar thing for me, different subject, obviously. Um
But I was always amazed that that was a book that didn't exist. And this is another book where like I'm just amazed that this doesn't exist already. Uh and so I think that's the kinda kind of thing I want to write into. Well, I have to write into existence. because it's a Yeah, because it's a
Alison Stratten (23:49)
I started it. I got it.
Ed S. (23:51)
book that I want to read. Yeah, exactly.
Alison Stratten (23:53)
That's really interesting. We actually, um, speaking to other authors, many authors pointed to some of the work that you talk about in your book, like when you make references to work like Octavia's Octavia Butler's work and to Stephen
Ed S. (24:03)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. For sure.
Alison Stratten (24:06)
King's work. And so it's this idea of these sort of like um alternate worlds and fantasies that
Ed S. (24:13)
Yeah.
Alison Stratten (24:13)
allow us to kind of work through some of the crises that are real. And and I thought that was
Ed S. (24:18)
For sure.
Alison Stratten (24:19)
very interesting. It's such a free
space to imagine and to be creative inside when we're facing crises. Yeah.
Ed S. (24:26)
For sure, for sure.
Alison Stratten (24:27)
Thank you so much for sharing
Ed S. (24:29)
Thank you. This is great.
Alison Stratten (24:30)
your time with me today. Um I'll have on the website all kinds of information about Ed and all the links and info you shared today and a place where people can go to learn more about your book and pick it up. Thank you so much for sharing your time with me today. I really appreciate it.
Ed S. (24:46)
Thanks so much. I
appreciate it. Thank you.
Alison Stratten (24:49)
Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Academic Book Club. Like, subscribe, and all that good stuff and visit academicbookclub.com to learn more about new and upcoming titles. Have feedback or suggestions from this episode? Ideas about who we have to speak to next? Reach out anytime and say hi on Instagram or by email to info at academicbookclub.com. Keep reading, take care, and talk soon.